Submitted by delores on Tue, 10/13/2009 - 11:34.
The Atlantic November issue has a superb story online about the effectiveness of flu vaccines and Tamiflu, quoting epidemiologist Tom Jefferson and examining the lack of scientific rigour in the studies about whether the flu vaccine actually prevents deaths or illnesses, and citing reserachers who claim the seeming results are just a "healthy worker" effect. The story includes these lines:
"As with vaccines, the scientific evidence for Tamiflu and Relenza is thin at best. In its general-information section, the CDC’s Web site tells readers that antiviral drugs can “make you feel better faster.” True, but not by much. On average, Tamiflu (which accounts for 85 to 90 percent of the flu antiviral-drug market) cuts the duration of flu symptoms by 24hours in otherwise healthy people. In exchange for a slightly shorter bout of illness, as many as one in five people taking Tamiflu will experience nausea and vomiting. About one in five children will have neuropsychiatric side effects, possibly including anxiety and suicidal behavior."
It does not delve into the fincial implications, stickinginstead to the medical debate, but does note that Tamiflu costs $10 a shot.
Read Does the Vaccine Matter? by Shannon Brownlee and Jeanne Lenzer in The Atlantic, and decide for yourself!